Holiday Wreath Contest Disrupted Following Dispute Over Magnolia Flag

Judging Panel, Longstanding Traditions, and a Canine Complication Noted

By staff writer, The Noble County Recorder

The Sanctuary Bay Holiday Market was briefly disrupted Saturday afternoon following a public dispute during the presentation of this year’s Wreath Decorating Contest award.

The disagreement arose moments after judges awarded the Magnolia Blossom Flag, traditionally displayed on the winner’s home for the year, to Ruby Gilroy, ending a ten-year winning streak held by Maybelle Everett.

Everett, well known for hearing difficulties, immediately objected to the decision, loudly accusing Gilroy of securing the award through what she described as “casting couch skills” in connection with one of the judges—a remark that drew audible reactions from across the market square.

Witnesses confirmed that the dispute escalated when Gilroy attempted to leave the judging area with the Magnolia Flag. Everett seized the award, resulting in a brief physical struggle. During the exchange, Gilroy fell, at which point Coco, Everett’s prize-winning Pomeranian, became agitated and nipped Gilroy on the leg.

Event volunteers intervened quickly, separating the parties. Several wreath displays sustained minor damage.

Mayor Loulou Tomlin confirmed that no arrests were made.

“Emotions ran high, voices carried, and a small dog became overstimulated,” the mayor said. “The situation was brought under control.”

EMTs treated Gilroy for minor lacerations. She declined to comment and left the market shortly thereafter. Everett was escorted away while continuing to dispute the judging process.

Readers Will Recall

The Magnolia Blossom Flag has flown on the Everett home for the past decade, making this year’s result a notable departure from tradition.

This year’s judging panel included local businessman Charles Habersham, whose presence drew attention from attendees familiar with past social connections involving multiple members of the community.

Habersham did not issue a statement regarding the incident.

Community Update

Event organizers confirmed that the contest results are under review, citing concerns related to conduct during the award presentation.

The Holiday Market reopened later that afternoon, though officials noted that additional measures may be considered for future competitions.

Residents are reminded that while holiday traditions are intended to foster goodwill, strong personalities, long memories, and competitive histories can occasionally complicate festive proceedings.